How to Compare Two Colour Grades in a Client Review
A client likes the warmth in version B, then asks for the faces from version A. You can act on that note once you know where the warmth belongs, which faces they mean, and whether they approved a look for the whole film or just the scene they saw.
Prepare two versions of the same excerpt and give the client one decision to make. Show both versions at normal speed, replay the shots that prompted the reaction, and leave the session with an approved direction plus a short list of exceptions.
Adobe is featuring Premiere Color Mode at MAX EMEA on November 10–11. Its September update described Auto Color in Color Mode beta as a way to adjust exposure and colour temperature across a clip, group, or sequence. If those controls help you prepare alternatives, a structured review helps the client decide which changes should carry forward. The comparison below works in any editing or grading application. Adobe MAX EMEA programme · Adobe’s September Premiere update
Give each version a purpose
Write down the question before making the second grade. For a short hospitality film, you might ask which direction makes the lobby feel welcoming while keeping the whites in the signage clean. This is a hypothetical brief. It gives the client two things to look for and gives you a way to interpret the answer.
Prepare A as the current reference and B as the proposed direction. Keep the cut, framing, audio, and output settings consistent. Limit B to the changes that answer the question. If you change the exposure, add grain, and reframe the opening shot together, a preference for B gives you very little information about which change mattered.
Choose an excerpt with a representative shot, a cut to a different lighting condition, and a shot that might resist the look. A flattering hero frame can sell a direction that falls apart when the camera cuts to a close-up. Keep an identifiable version label and a timecode reference handy for each excerpt.
Play the comparison in the right order
- State the decision. Tell the client which sequence and versions they are seeing and what you want them to approve in this round.
- Play A and B in full. Use the same start and end points. Give each version enough time for the viewer to register the scene and the transition between shots.
- Replay the point that prompted the note. Switch at the same frame when the client is pointing at a detail. Then run through the cut again so the group can judge whether the adjustment still works in motion.
- Read back the decision. State which version to carry forward, where it applies, and what you will check or revise before the next review.
If people ask to blend the versions, bring the discussion down to a visible change. “Keep B’s warmth in the practical lamps and bring the complexion closer to A in the close-up” gives the colourist a starting point. Replay the close-up beside the shot before it to find out whether the preference concerns the complexion on its own or the jump between the two shots.
Separate a look decision from a finishing decision
A live conversation can settle the intent of a scene and surface the shots that need attention. Use a controlled viewing setup for judgements that depend on precise display behaviour, such as where shadow detail disappears or whether a small tint is present in the master. For a remote session, agree which decisions are suitable for the viewing conditions before inviting the approver. Flow encoder guide and colour pipeline notes
If two viewers describe the same shot differently, ask each what they can see and capture the version and timecode. Have the finishing owner inspect that shot against the intended output on their reference setup. You can still agree on the direction for the rest of the sequence and record the disputed shot for a separate check.
The guide to livestreaming a colour grade covers preparing the session. For a follow-up that only needs confirmation of a specific revision, the live and async review guide can help you choose how to send it.
Capture the scope of the approval
Record the decision where the editor and colourist already track revisions. Use the same labels and timecode reference that appeared in the session. Here is a worked note for the hypothetical hospitality film.
Sequence | Lobby film v07, 00:18–00:32
Compared | Grade A v03 and Grade B v02
Decision | Use B's warm direction in the lobby sequence
Exception | At 00:24, bring the close-up complexion toward A
Owner | Colourist
Next check | Replay the close-up with its two neighbouring shots
Finishing | Inspect signage whites and shadow detail on the reference setup
This note gives the next pass a boundary. The lobby decision applies to a named part of the cut. The exception has a location and a test. The finishing checks have a clear place in the handoff.
For your next comparison, queue two labelled excerpts and write the decision question before anyone joins. If the team needs to see the switch and discuss the shot together, try a live session in FlowLabs using the documented encoder setup. Try a grade review in FlowLabs